All-Star Debate: Paris vs. Nicole

Best friends forever... not! During the first three seasons of The Simple Life, pampered socialites Paris Hilton and Nicole Richie seemed to share everything ‑- beauty tips, clothes, a brain. The clueless cutups amused us and amassed a huge following. Just when we thought they'd start sporting those best friends pendants (from Tiffany or somewhere très chic, of course), Paris dropped a bomb in a statement: "It's no big secret that Nicole and I are no longer friends. Nicole knows what she did, and that's all I'm ever going to say about it." Dra-ma! Insiders whispered that Paris was peeved Nic screened the hotel heiress's One Night in Paris porn tape for friends, but Nicole never revealed any details as to why their friendship went south.

Here's the kicker: While you or we would just avoid said friend (like the plague!), Paris and Nicole are contractually obligated to film a fourth season of The Simple Life. Fox has a final season of the show in the works, focusing on the big splashy weddings that both newly engaged divas are planning. And to add fuel to the fire, the girls have competing movies coming out on the very same weekend in November. Needless to say, this bitter feud is just going to grow stronger in the coming months. So join our debate and tell us which camp you're in and why. Are you on Nicole's side? Pulling for Paris? Would you like to see them reconcile? Who do you think is the guilty party? Spill it.

members say: